If family is an American value, why are we so family unfriendly?

If you have kids, then you know how unfriendly public places can be to families. Two significant instances to begin:

1. It is extremely difficult to find a changing table most places. I’ve yet to find a changing table at a rest stop and we have driven back and forth between Iowa, Oklahoma, and Texas A LOT. Gas stations are just as bad.

2. Breastfeeding is a contentious issue in the U.S. The rate of mothers breastfeeding is atrocious despite the overwhelming health benefits and we live in a culture that insists breastfeeding moms “cover up” to do so. As demonstrated on this facebook fan page, breastfeeding has only recently been devalued in American culture to the detriment of society at large. If we truly wanted the very best for our children, then wouldn’t it be a family value to nurture a culture that encouraged breastfeeding rather than establishing obstacles to its success (such as workplace incompatibilities andd cultural taboos that teach women to view their bodies as a sexual objects rather than vital entities that give and nurture life)?

What prompted this post was my train of thought this morning as I contemplate getting alternative certification to teach at the secondary level. There are many perks, and if you teach at a Title I school, you qualify for federal student loan forgiveness in ten years. My student loans are weighing heavily on me right now since I’ll be unemployed and deeply in debt in three months. But through my mental meanderings earlier today, as I considered why poor schools must search for teachers in ways that more affluent schools don’t, it led me to think of one more major problem in a country that supposedly places so much importance on family: the lack of paid family leave. I was thinking this morning about the cold snap a few months ago that prompted schools in Oklahoma to cancel classes for the day. It seemed odd until my teacher friends pointed out that many kids had no jackets and yet their parents would send them to school anyways. Good point- but then I thought, many of those parents probably didn’t have jobs that would allow them to take off to care for their children if they wouldn’t/didn’t buy them heavy jackets.

And so, we have the problem: we live in a country that will bend over backwards to deny certain groups in society the ability to marry and have families and attempts to control a woman’s reproductive choices. The Family Medical Leave Act is helpful but leaves much to be desired, such as paid family leave. And if you’re in particular jobs that are typically low-wage, I’m not sure the FMLA even applies. We can all pray for a sympathetic boss, but without full protection under the law that takes into consideration the many contingencies of having a family and does not penalize workers for having them, the so-called “family values” crowd has a ways to go before they gain any more credibility with skeptics like me.


2 thoughts on “If family is an American value, why are we so family unfriendly?

  1. interesting points….i hadn’t even thought about this but i’m sure it’s true:
    “but then I thought, many of those parents probably didn’t have jobs that would allow them to take off to care for their children if they wouldn’t/didn’t buy them heavy jackets”

  2. You’re thinking like a teacher 🙂 Society is a mess of double standards. I will tell you that Chick fil a is probably the most family friendly place, and one of the only places I will take my kids alone. And you’re so right about the school issue……that has to do with the schools covering their butts so the parents that can’t afford to buy a coat for their kids don’t sue the school because their kid slips on the ice (at school) or whatever. About breastfeeding…..I don’t totally understand what it is like since I never have, but I totally agree that it is ridiculous that our society isn’t supportive of breastfeeding moms because what seems to be a sexual issue. Boobs are just for sex, didn’t you know that?! On the flip side of that, moms that formula feed are made to feel guilty because we aren’t breastfeeding, that I can definitely tell you about. But anyway, it seems no matter which way you go the family values and being supportive of families does not exist in our society the way people without kids think it does.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s